An overview
MediaSpace.GaTech.edu/media/A+spatiotemporal+theory+of+coupled+map+lattices/1_a9gcyq4w
over the current draft of
Domenico Lippolis domenico.lippolis@riken.jpPredrag Cvitanović predrag.cvitanovic@physics.gatech.edu.
Very detailed. Recommended for coauthors of the Tigers and Coupled papers, as well as anyone who would like to apply the spatiotemporal theory of Navier-Stokes turbulence, and is able to (or understands what that means) compute numerically exact coherent structures of a given system.
ZOOM AI : Quick recap
The meeting focused on Predrag reviewing a draft paper with Domenico about computing stability exponents for spatiotemporal solutions in a reaction-diffusion system. Predrag explained that their approach finds numerically exact space-time solutions on an infinite space-time rather than discretizing on a box and taking a limit. They discussed the structure of the introduction, emphasizing the use of a diagonal term and a term talking to neighbors in the orbit Jacobian, and how this relates to loop expansions and field theory. They compared different types of solutions, such as steady states, synchronized states, and non-synchronized states, and discussed the stability of a checkerboard-like state. Predrag also explained a method for computing the determinant of the orbit Jacobian using a loop expansion based on walks on the lattice, which avoids the need for matrix diagonalization. The conversation touched on the difference between first-order and second-order equations in time and space and how this affects the possible walks on the lattice.
Next steps
Domenico
- Try to compute the stability exponent for the generic "brick" (spatiotemporal state [3x2]_1 with period 3 in space, 2 in time, and slant 1) using the loop expansion/walks method.
Predrag
- Remove "pompous bullshit" like "21st century" from the introduction and censor/edit the text as needed.
- Define the Bravais cell notation, Brillouin zone, Bloch's theorem, and mosaics (symbolic dynamics in space-time) in the paper, either in the main text or appendices.
- Standardize the notation in the paper, including changing "T" and "t" where they were inverted and using standard notation for the orbit Jacobian and shifts.
- Add the "formula (38)" equivalent from CL18 to the paper, showig that in the anti-integrable limit, only the local potential terms dominate.
- Include the brick wall figures for the [2x1]_0 and [2x1]_1 states to clarify the difference between synchronized and non-synchronized steady states.
- Use official notation throughout (e.g., L, T, S) for different types of states instead of "synchronized, non-synchronized, tilted/checkerboard, ..." descriptive terms.
Summary
Field Theory Numerical Calculations Planning
Predrag discussed plans for a paper about numerical calculations in field theory, explaining their approach of finding exact space-time solutions rather than discretizing on a box. He outlined the paper's structure, which would cover the commonalities between field theory calculations and reaction-diffusion systems, including the use of separable forms with diagonal and neighbor-coupling terms. Predrag explained their motivation for using Chebyshev polynomials, connecting to previous work by Beck and Dettmann, and noted the need to include definitions of Bravais lattices, reciprocal lattices, and mosaics in the paper's appendices.
Periodic Orbits Matrix Representation
Brandon's calculation of time periodic orbits synchronized in space with arbitrary time periods, focused on a matrix representation where spatial dimensions are local and temporal dimensions form blocks based on the period. The anti-integrable limit where local potential terms dominate is also in CL18 and stability.tex of blogCats.tex.
Lattice Systems Steady States Discussion
Predrag discussed different types of steady states in lattice systems, claiming that he word "synchronization" is not useful in chaotic setting: there are cases where states are synchronized in space and time, periodic in space but steady in time, and non-synchronized steady states with periodicity in time. Predrag explained the concept of primitive cells and the Hermite convention, which helps define unique Bravais lattices by ensuring one primitive vector is horizontal.
Spatial Periodicity in Brick Patterns
Predrag explained the concept of spatial and temporal periodicity in brick patterns, using the [3x2]_1 brick example to illustrate how different patterns form when bricks are shifted horizontally. He discussed how the appendix applies to computing eigenvalues for spatially periodic systems, particularly for second-order difference equations. The discussion focused on deriving formulas for synchronized states and periodic systems, with Predrag noting that while volume 6 eigenvalues can only be computed numerically and need to be computed, the [3x2]_1 example provides a good generic case for understanding the broader pattern formation.
Steady States and Bifurcations Analysis
Predrag and Domenico discussed the analysis of different steady states and their stability in a system, focusing on comparing figures and understanding bifurcations. They clarified the distinction between the anti-integrable limit (A=0) and full coupling (A=1), and discussed the importance of checkerboard patterns in fluid dynamics. Predrag again encouraged Domenico to work on the generic brick [3x2]_1 case. Domenico demurred again.
Spatial Coupling and Stability Analysis
Predrag explained the concept of coupling in spatial and temporal dimensions, discussing how parameter A measures the strength of coupling between spatial neighbors. He described how in their specific parameterization, spatial neighbor interactions lead to bifurcations, and explained the mathematical approach for computing stability exponents using trace logarithm methods and lattice walks. The discussion focused on understanding how different walks on the lattice contribute to the final stability calculations, particularly in one-dimensional cases where spatial diffusion is considered without time components.
Lattice Walks Determinant Computation Method
Predrag explained a method for computing determinants using lattice walks, demonstrating how to apply it to periodic systems by analyzing walks on a [3x2]_0 and [3x2]_1 periodic cells. He showed that the approach involves counting finite walks that explore the lattice and using these to construct expressions for the determinant in terms of lattice site values. The discussion included blogCats.tex subfile stability.tex examples of first and second-order time dependencies and how to handle different orders of spatial and temporal perturbations. Predrag emphasized that while the calculations can be complex, they can be easily implemented using Mathematica, and simpler, as he had done 50 years ago. The method ultimately connects to Brillouin zone calculations in the continuum limit.
Attendees: Predrag Cvitanović, Domenico Lippolis
Escapees: Matt Gold, Francesco Fedele
:
